Normally, I stick to tech hardware. Today, though, I am taking a look at a great doorway pull-up bar. You can do plenty of exercises in the comfort of your own home without equipment. This is one of the few exceptions. I set out to find a low cost, safe option for doing this exercise at home (and prepping for more Spartan Races!)
A quick Amazon search yields plenty of options for pull-up bars you can use at home. In fact, the top 3 matches are all the same price and look fairly similar. I began to wonder, “what makes these chin-up and pull-up bars different from each other? How do these things not destroy door frames in my house? Most importantly, how do I properly measure for a pull-up bar?”
Ultimately, I went with Amazon Prime’s #1 best seller by a company called ProSource, not to be confused with the commercial fitness equipment company of the same name … or the fitness supplement company of the same name … or the many other companies of the same name.
I don’t tend to buy based on popularity. After all, the $1 Totino’s party pizza is the “America’s best selling frozen pizza”, but that doesn’t make it any good.
All of these bars are made in China. A couple have slightly different variations in hardware and packaging. P90X had the bar tested independently at Integrity Testing Labs, where they claim to have subjected it to 500 pounds for 200,000 repetitions. They compare it to the slightly different Iron Gym bar, claiming the competition failed after a fourth of the reps. They also doubled the price and added an additional $15 shipping! No thanks!
SolidlyStated chooses the ProSource bar for the following reasons:
- Durability and construction is solid
- Price is low
- Quality of fit and finish is high. Product looks and feels great. No odors
- Quality fasteners and optional mounting hardware
- Quality and simplicity of directions. 15-20 minute assembly with provided tool
- Reviews. Other seller reviews show missing/cheap fasteners or rusted pieces
- Multiple chin-up and pull-up grip positions. Box says 12, but I count 8
Measure Twice, Order Once
Will any of these bars work for you? If you have standard doors in your home, you will be fine. The width measurement is the obvious one. However, there are 2 more pitfalls with these types of bars.
First is the depth of your door frame. This type of bar distributes weight throughout the front and back of the doorway. Certain doorways are deeper, such as older homes with 8+ inches. You need a 5.5″ to 6.5″ depth for this unit.
Secondly, watch out for nearby perpendicular walls. Half of my doors are at corners, meaning the bar hits one side. This style of bar is 41 inches long, so measure your intended destination first.
The Width Measurement
Solid Tip: When measuring width for your bar, measure the door itself, rounding up to nearest inch. Don’t try to measure the frame.
My standard interior doors are 24 and 30 inches. These bars officially support between 24 and 32. However, 24 inch doors are a very poor fit for this bar.
In a 24 inch door
Notice how these posts sit halfway on the door frame and will dig into it. Not ideal.
In a 30 inch door
A good fit. 30-32 is the ideal door width.
Don’t Damage your Door Frames
Most people have fancy frame moulding around their doors. It will get dented through light use of this bar. Do yourself a favor and stick some cardboard behind it or get creative and wrap it. One reviewer used boxer’s tape around the bar.
At the end of the day, its a cheap metal bar. Get this one and don’t look back. The other sellers seem to have a lot of issues.
- Product Box Dimensions: 44 x 10.5 x 2 inches
- Bar Length: 41 inches
- Shipping Weight: 9.8 pounds
- Bar Weight: 9.5 pounds
Some Final Notes
Pull-up bars are not adjustable. It may seem like something a customer would want, but when you exert hundreds of pounds of force on a metal bar, you want it to be a solid piece that doesn’t move.
The foam grips certainly aren’t the quality you would find on gym equipment (which would be rubber). That’s because this is a $30 item. They look like they will last.
It takes 5 seconds to put this bar up or take it down.
These bars are rated for a 300 pound person.